Are you dreaming of a perfect beach day during your Caribbean cruise but can’t decide between Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay? These two private island destinations are owned by Carnival Corporation.
These islands offer pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and endless opportunities for relaxation and adventure. Both islands promise a slice of paradise, but each has its own unique charm and features that set them apart.
Whether you’re seeking thrilling water sports, serene beaches, or family-friendly activities, understanding the differences between these tropical havens will help you make the most of your cruise stop.
Let’s dive into a detailed comparison of Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cay to help you decide which island paradise is right for your next cruise vacation.
Princess Cays Vs Half Moon Cay Key Differences
Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay are both beautiful destinations owned by the Carnival Corporation in the Bahamas, located just 15 miles apart from each other. While Princess Cays is situated on Eleuthera Island, Half Moon Cay is its own private island.
Both islands are located less than 300 miles from Miami, making them perfect stops for Caribbean cruises.
Both destinations offer cruise passengers a chance to experience stunning beaches and various activities, but each has its own unique features that might make one more appealing than the other depending on your preferences.
Following is the difference between Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cays:
Island Location, Size and Characteristics
The most notable difference between the two islands is their size and overall layout.
Princess Cays occupies a relatively modest 40-acre area on the southern tip of Eleuthera Island. Despite its name, Princess Cays is not a cay or a complete island, but rather a resort on Eleuthera, located around 50 miles from Nassau.
In contrast, Half Moon Cay is a massive 2,400-acre private island located midway between Eleuthera and Cat Island. It is reserved exclusively for cruise passengers and is about 100 miles southeast of Nassau
This significant size difference means Half Moon Cay offers a more expansive, secluded experience, while Princess Cays has a more intimate, compact feel.
You can also read about “Perfect Day At CocoCay” which is Royal Caribbean Private Island.
Half Moon Cay vs Princess Cays Transportation
Both islands utilize tender boats to transfer guests from the cruise ships to the shore, but their on-island transportation differs.
Half Moon Cay provides a tram service that shuttles visitors between the Welcome Center and the main dining area throughout the day.
Princess Cays, on the other hand, offers motorized carts primarily for transporting guests with cabana reservations.
This difference can impact how easily and efficiently you can move around each island.
Half Moon Cay vs Princess Cays Excursions
Each island provides unique adventure options. Half Moon Cay specializes in land-based activities like horseback riding on the beach, Beach volleyball, Basketball court, eco-bike tours, and hiking trails.
Water base activities include snorkeling, kayaking, paddle boarding, jet skiing, parasailing, deep-sea fishing and stingray encounter.
Princess Cays excels in water-based activities, offering coastal cruising, sailboat rentals, Banana boat rides and clear-bottom kayak tours. The shoreline and wildlife at Princess Cays are more accommodating to aquatic species, leading to a greater variety of marine life for snorkeling.
One downside of Princess Cays is the presence of more bugs compared to Half Moon Cay. Visitors to Princess Cays should be sure to pack insect repellent to minimize any disturbances.
Since Princess Cays is connected to the island of Eleuthera, visitors can explore the nearby villages, such as Rock Sound and Tarpum Bay.
In contrast, guests at Half Moon Cay are limited to the activities provided by the cruise line on the island.
Bar Services and Drink Packages
Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay offer extensive beverage service through multiple bars across their properties.
Princess Cays features bars like Reef Runners Bar, Coconuts, Palm Groove, Bahia Bar, and Banana Beach Bar, while Half Moon Cay bars are Rumrunners, I Wish I Could Stay Here Forever Bar, Captain Morgan’s (uniquely situated on a pirate ship), and Bell Bar.
A significant distinction between the two islands lies in their drink package policies.
Note: Princess Cruises Drink Packages work at Princess Cays, Carnival’s Cheers package cannot be used at either destination. Conversely, Half Moon Cay requires separate payment for drinks, though Holland America Line guests have the option to purchase a specific island drink package, while Carnival Cruise guests must pay for individual drinks.
Private Retreat Options
Both Half Moon Cay and Princess Cays offer private rental options for visitors seeking a more exclusive experience during their island visit.
Half Moon Cay features air-conditioned cabanas starting at $280 per day for four guests, with the option to add more guests for an additional fee. They also offer luxurious two-story villas starting at $500 for eight guests, and for those seeking ultimate luxury, there are premium options starting at $1,600 that include a private chef, butler, lifeguard, and bartender.
Princess Cays provides air-conditioned bungalows starting at $210 per day, including special options in The Sanctuary, an adults-only area. For budget-conscious visitors, Princess Cays also offers clamshell rentals for basic beach shade.
Both destinations have limited availability for these private spaces, so early booking is strongly recommended to secure a spot.
Note: It’s important to note that all prices are subject to change, and guests should verify current rates directly with their cruise line before booking.
Princess Cay vs Half Moon Cay Shopping
Both Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay provide opportunities for visitors to shop for souvenirs and local handicrafts, though their offerings differ in scope and variety.
Princess Cays features the Tropical Treasures boutique along with a local crafts market that focuses primarily on Bahamian items, though the selection is somewhat limited.
Half Moon Cay, on the other hand, offers a more extensive shopping experience with multiple gift shops, a traditional straw market, and a wider variety of local artisan crafts.
Both destinations conveniently accept U.S. currency for all purchases, making shopping easy for cruise passengers.
Princess Cays maintains a simpler shopping atmosphere, but Half Moon Cay provides a more diverse range of shopping options, making it a better choice for those interested in extensive souvenir hunting.
Beach Experience and Terrain
When it comes to the beaches, Half Moon Cay stands out for its soft, powdery white sand that many visitors consider superior for strolling, swimming, and lounging.
Princess Cays, on the other hand, has slightly coarser sand with some rocky areas, which may require guests to bring water shoes for exploration.
Both islands boast crystal-clear turquoise waters, but the differences in beach texture create distinct experiences for beachgoers.
Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cay Similarities
Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay, two Bahamian islands share several key features that create comparable vacation experiences for cruise passengers. From their weather patterns and basic beach amenities to dining options and water activities, these destinations have more in common than you might expect.
Let’s explore the similarities between Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay that make both islands equally appealing tropical getaways.
Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cays Weather
When comparing the weather at these two Bahamian island destinations, both Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay share remarkably similar climate patterns, with warm temperatures year-round that make them ideal tropical getaways.
Half Moon Cay experiences slightly higher peak temperatures, reaching up to 90°F (32°C), while Princess Cays stays a bit cooler with summer highs around 85°F (29°C).
Both islands follow the same seasonal pattern, with a wet season from May to October featuring afternoon thunderstorms, and a drier, sunnier period during winter months that coincides with peak cruise season. These islands are also susceptible to hurricane activity between June and November.
For visitors planning their cruise, both destinations offer equally appealing weather conditions, with the winter months being popular due to mild temperatures and minimal rainfall.
Arrival and Access (Tender Boats)
One similarity shared by both Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay is the requirement of tender boat service to reach the shore from the cruise ships.
This shared characteristic means both can face similar weather-related cancellations when conditions are unfavorable.
The tendering process is well-organized at both locations, though timing can vary based on sea conditions
Basic Amenities
Both islands provide complimentary beach chairs and hammocks on a first-come, first-served basis, as well as a free barbecue lunch service.
Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay both offer a casual dining experience with classic beach fare like burgers, hot dogs, and salads.
Swimming in the ocean is free at both locations, making them perfect for budget-conscious travelers.
Water Activities and Equipment
Both Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay provide similar water activity options including snorkeling, kayaking, and floating equipment rentals. Stingray encounters are available at both locations, along with various water-based tours and activities.
Equipment rental processes are similar, with convenient pickup locations near the beach areas.
Dining Experience
Both Half Moon Cay and Princess Cays offer complimentary lunch options for their visitors, though the service is available only during specific hours between 11:30 AM and 1:30 PM.
At Half Moon Cay guests can enjoy a variety of dishes at the Tropics Restaurant including burgers, chicken, and tacos, while also having the option to purchase seafood entrees at the Lobster Shack for an additional cost.
Princess Cays provides its complimentary lunch service through two pavilions, where visitors can find a selection of burgers, hot dogs, ribs, and salads.
The BBQ buffet style service at both locations ensures guests can enjoy a satisfying meal during their island visit. However, visitors should carefully note the lunch schedule for their specific cruise as timing may vary, ensuring they don’t miss the complimentary meal service.
Both Half Moon Cay and Princess Cays don’t offer all-day dining options, so planning your activities around the lunch service is essential for the best experience.
Half Moon Cay vs Princess Cays Reviews
Half Moon Cay is a favorite among cruisers, known for its soft white sand, crystal-clear waters, and top-notch facilities. Many highlight the serene atmosphere, excellent snorkeling, and luxurious private cabanas. The BBQ lunch and attentive staff service add to the island’s charm, making it one of the most popular stops in the Caribbean.
Princess Cays also offers a great beach day, with water sports and a convenient layout praised by visitors. However, the sand is noted to be less soft, and the area can feel more crowded compared to Half Moon Cay.
Both islands provide excellent service, but Half Moon Cay’s larger size and superior amenities make it a standout choice for cruisers seeking a relaxing and unforgettable experience.
Final Thoughts
Choose Half Moon Cay if you prefer:
- Softer and more pristine beaches
- A larger and more secluded island experience
- Nature-focused activities like horseback riding
- More extensive walking and exploration opportunities
- A bug-free environment
Choose Princess Cays if you prefer:
- The option to explore local villages
- Using your ship’s drink package on land
- Closer proximity of bars to the beach
- Better snorkeling opportunities
- The flexibility to venture beyond the cruise area
Remember that your final choice might ultimately depend on your cruise line and itinerary selection, as different ships visit different islands.
Both destinations excel at providing a relaxing beach day experience with plenty of amenities and activities to enjoy.
Tips for Both Destinations
- Book excursions early
- Arrive early for best beach spots
- Bring cash for local vendors
- Pack water shoes
- Remember sunscreen
- Consider clamshell/cabana rental
FAQs – Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cay
Which is Better Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cay?
Princess Cays and Half Moon Cay are both private islands offering relaxing beach experiences. Princess Cays is great for a quieter vibe and snorkeling, while Half Moon Cay stands out for its stunning powdery sand and lagoon-like water. Both are lovely, but Half Moon Cay is often considered more picturesque and perfect for a classic beach day.
Is Princess Cays Safe?
Princess Cays is considered a very safe destination for cruise passengers, as it’s a private island operated by Carnival Corporation with dedicated security staff and limited access to outside visitors. The beach areas are well-monitored, facilities are maintained to high safety standards, and all activities are supervised by trained staff, making it a secure choice for families and solo travelers alike.
Is Half Moon Cay Safe?
Half Moon Cay is extremely safe for visitors, as it’s a private island operated by Carnival Corporation with controlled access and constant security presence. The island maintains strict safety protocols for all activities, employs professional lifeguards at swimming areas, and features well-maintained facilities, making it a secure destination for travelers of all ages.
- Wonder of the Seas Size Comparison 2025: Length, Capacity, & Gross Tonnage - January 20, 2025
- Icon of the Seas Rooms: Suites & Cabins Guide 2025 - January 20, 2025
- MSC Theme Nights 2025 Schedule for All Ships - January 19, 2025